Ask Joanne - My daughter's scared of being alone
Categories: Kids+, Development, Behaviour and Development, Ask Joanne
What burning questions about parenting do you have? Our life coach Joanne Mallon is here with a sympathetic ear and practical suggestions. Email your question to Joanne at this address and say if you'd like your name changed.
Pippa writes:
I've realised my daughters don't spend any time alone. The other day we were messing about and we said we would all list things we were scared of. For one of my daughters, coming in at number three was 'being alone' - which made me think - what do you suggest we do to either reassure her or let her be alone?
She is only 10, and does get plenty of time away from us and her sister as we have always done our best to make sure they aren't always doing the same things and are growing in independence. We need to encourage her to enjoy her own company! Thanks!
Here's life coach Joanne's reply:
Dear Pippa
I agree with you that it's a good skill to foster if you can encourage your daughter to be more comfortable in her own company. But bear in mind that many adults don't particularly like being alone, and she may turn out to be one of those people. So maybe the challenge here is to make being alone less fearful, even if it's not something that she might choose to do all that often.
It sounds like you've already had a good conversation about fears, so maybe you could take that a step further. Specifically, what is she afraid might happen? What's her reason for thinking this? If her worst fear did come true, how would she deal with this? She will feel more empowered if she has a plan to deal with the situation. So make sure she is comfortable using the telephone or going to a neighbour's house in an emergency.
It may be more useful to quietly build in some alone time for her, without making a big deal of it - send her out to the shop, or nip out for 5 minutes yourself. Don't point it out beforehand ("I am leaving you alone now") but afterwards, casually mention that she was alone, and she coped with it fine. This will build her confidence.
I have been in this situation, as I have started to leave my daughter alone since she turned 9. She absolutely loves it and sees it as a huge grown up treat to be home alone. But when I mentioned it to one of her friend's mums, she was absolutely horrified and would not consider letting her child stay home without an adult.
I think that at this age, you have to treat the child as an individual and encourage their independence, as much as they are ready to be independent. Your daughter may simply not be ready for much alone time right now, but in six months that could all change and you'll be lucky if she wants to be with you at all. So maybe enjoy it while it lasts!
Best wishes
Joanne
More parenting advice from here in the Ask Joanne section
Send your question in to Joanne at this address
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Fiz 9-10-2009 @ 4:04PM
If this is the UK you are talking about, it's illegal to leave a child under 14 alone.
Reply
Joanne Mallon 9-11-2009 @ 3:10AM
Hi Fiz - thank you very much for your comment, you bring up a good point. Whilst it is a widely held belief that there is a minimum legal age for leaving your child alone in the UK, in fact there is none.
More on this and some good guidelines from the NSPCC here: http://www.nspcc.org.uk/helpandadvice/parentsandcarers/homealone/homealone_wda35965.html
christine scott 9-12-2009 @ 3:41AM
i think 9 years old is far to young to leave a child alone.
Reply
Lee 9-16-2009 @ 3:57AM
I really think that's up to the parents to decide - they know their children best. My sister used to stand on the end of the drive and watch my niece as she went to the village shop on an errand. She was only about 9 at the time and was thrilled to be given the chance.
Meanwhile, she won't leave my 14-year-old nephew on his own for the night because she doesn't trust him not to burn the house down by accident.
I was often left on my own at the age of 9 (though never for very long) and I loved having the opportunity to rifle through my mother's jewellery drawer trying things on. I certainly wasn't in danger of doing anything stupid - I was too sensible for that!
Reply
evaling 9-21-2009 @ 6:57AM
It may be helpful to find out what exactly she means by being alone. Does she fear being at home on her own? Does she not like spending time on her own (for instance, playing alone, in her own room). She might think of 'not having any friends' as being alone, or maybe she just meant: being all alone in the world, without her family to fall back on. Not all "I don't like being alone"s stem from the same source and unless you know what she meant it is perhaps a bit early to make a plan.
Reply