Don't let parents find out the sex of their baby until 30 weeks, says top doctor
Filed under: Pregnancy & Birth
Email This
Text Size
A
A
A
Comments
PA
Dr. Rajendra Kale, editor-in-chief of the Canadian Medical Association Journal, says keeping the sex from parents-to-be would prevent abortions being carried out on the basis of the child's gender.
He said this was a major issue in some Asian countries, where parents wanted sons rather than daughters.
Whilst agreeing that women have the right to information about their own health and medical care, Dr. Kale, who is from Mumbai, India, says this does not include the sex of the foetus, as this has no impact on the mother's care.
He said the only exception should be in cases of rare illnesses.
Writing in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, Dr. Kale says: "A pregnant woman being told the sex of the foetus at ultrasonography at a time when an unquestioned abortion is possible is the starting point of sex selection."
In America, expectant mums usually have two scans, one at 18 weeks and one at 22 weeks into their pregnancy. In UK, mums-to-be have one at 12 weeks and another around 22 weeks, when you can ask to find out the sex.
The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists of Canada both agree that sex selection is unethical, but, reports the Daily Mail, they also say that not telling a woman who has asked the sex of her child is also unethical.
What do you think?
Do you agree with Dr. Kale, or is it a parent's right to know the sex of their baby if they want to?
More on Parentdish:
The pros and cons of finding out the sex of your unborn baby
Our reader Claire shares her experience of 4D scans
- Chris and Natasha Evans<p> Chris and Natasha are expecting their second 'miracle' child in 2012, after an an ectopic pregnancy and IVF treatment. Chris confirmed the couple's happy news with the message: "Mrs E is in the family way once again. And yes, I can confirm she is . . . Thank you so much to the people who made it possible. We are eternally grateful. You make dreams come true."</p>
- Chantelle Houghton and Alex Reid<p> After a whirlwind romance, reality star Chantelle <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2011/11/15/chantelle-houghton-pregnant-with-alex-reid-baby/" target="_blank">announced</a> she was pregnant with Katie Price's ex, Alex Reid, in, of course, OK! magazine. The TV girl reckons she's set to be the "yummiest mummy there is" when she gives birth to the couple's first baby.</p> <p> </p>
- Kourtney Kardashian and Scott Disick<p> Kourtney and Scott are <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2011/11/30/reality-tv-star-kourtney-kardashian-is-expecting-baby-number-two-scott-disick-pregnant/" target="_blank">expecting their second baby</a> in June next year. They are already proud parents to two-year-old Mason. Kourtney announced her pregnancy before her 12 week scan as she was so excited to share her news, saying: "Now I'm nine weeks along. You're supposed to wait <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2011/04/16/pregnancy-week-by-week-week-12/" target="_blank">12 weeks</a> to tell people, but I feel confident."</p>
- Gary Barlow and wife Dawn<p> Gary kick-started a Take That baby news trend when he <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/02/20/gary-barlow-to-be-a-dad-for-the-fourth-time/" target="_blank">announced his wife Dawn is expecting their fourth baby, a little girl, later this year.</a> "My wife and I are expecting our 4th child #Anotherowngoal" he tweeted, cheekily adding: "Celebrity Dad of the Year #moveasideandre!" Mark and Robbie are also set to be dads this year.</p>
- Alsyon Hannigan<p> After dodging pregnancy rumours over the last year, Buffy and How I Met Your Mother star Alyson Hannigan <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2011/12/20/alyson-hannigan-pregnant-with-second-baby/" target="_blank">announced she was pregnant</a> with her second baby in December. The actress and husband, Alexis Denisof, are already proud parents to two-year-old Stayana. </p>
- Sienna Miller<p> Sienna and boyfriend, Tom Sturridge are expecting their first baby this year. The actress has been keeping mum over her growing baby bump, but her sister Savannah can't stop talking about it, telling Vogue: "She is doing really well and we are all really happy about it, Tom is an amazing guy.”</p>
- Uma Thurman and Arpad Busson<p> American actress Uma is <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/02/28/uma-thurman-pregnant-with-third-baby-at-41-arpad-busson-ex-elle-macpherson/" target="_blank">expecting her third baby</a> aged 41. She is already mum to Maya, 13, and Levon, 10, her children from her relationship with Ethan Hawke, while Arpad also has two children, Arpad Flynn Alexandra and Aurelius Cy Andrea, with former girlfriend, Elle Macpherson.</p>
- Rosamund Pike<p> Glamourous Bond girl Rosamund, 33, is reportedly <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/02/27/bond-girl-with-a-bump-rosamund-pike-reportedly-seven-months-pregnant/" target="_blank">seven months pregnant</a> with her first baby. This will be her first child with older businessman Robie Uniacke, 49, who she has been dating since 2009.</p>
- Tori Spelling<p> 90210 star Tori made a surprise announcement in March - she's <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/03/24/tori-spelling-pregnant-again/" target="_blank">pregnant with baby number four,</a> just five months after giving birth to her third baby, Hattie. The American actress is also mum to Liam, five, and Stella, three with husband, Dean McDermott.</p>
- Ray Quinn and Emma Stephens<p> X Factor and Dancing on Ice star Ray is set to be a dad in July. His new wife, West End star Emma is expecting the couple's first baby this summer. Emma told <a href="http://www.hellomagazine.com/celebrities/201204097689/ray-quinn-marries-emma-stephens/" target="_blank">Hello magazine</a>: "We were thrilled when we found out. We're deeply in love and having a baby together feels so right."</p>
- Robbie Williams and Ayda Field<p> Robbie is over the moon to be a first time dad-to-be. The cheeky singer <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/03/30/robbie-williams-and-ayda-field-are-expecting-their-first-baby/" target="_blank">announced his and wife Ayda's news</a> with the message: "Hey friendlies, I've been keeping a secret from you all. Me and Ayda are going to be a Mummy and Daddy this year!!!!!!!! We had sex! It works!"</p>
- Mark Owen and Emma Ferguson<p> Take That star Mark is set to be a <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/04/02/mark-owen-reveals-baby-hat-trick-third-take-that-star-to-make-baby-news/" target="_blank">dad for the third time</a> - his wife Emma is pregnant again. The couple are already proud parents to Elwood Jack, six, and Willow Rose, four. Mark is the third Take That member to announce baby news - Robbie and Gary are also dads-to-be!</p>
- Melissa Joan Hart<p> Former Sabrina the Teenage Witch actress Melissa <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/04/18/melissa-joan-hart-pregnant-with-third-baby/" target="_blank">announced she was expecting baby number three</a> on her 36th birthday. She is already mum to Mason, six, and Braydon, four, her boys with husband, Mark Wilkerson. </p>
- Reese Witherspoon<p> Reece hasn't actually confirmed her pregnancy herself, but her swelling belly certainly has! She's rumoured to be expecting her third baby, her first with new husband Jim Toth later this year. She is already mum to Ava and Deacon, her children with ex-husband Ryan Phillippe.</p>
- Anna Paquin<p> True Blood star Anna is expecting her first baby with co-star Stephen Moyer this Autumn. She's also getting in plenty of practice being step mum to Stephen's two children, Lilac and Billy.</p>
- Sarah Michelle Gellar<p> Hollywood couple Sarah and Freddie Prince Jr are rumoured to be e<a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/04/27/sarah-michelle-gellar-and-freddie-prinze-jr-expecting-second-bab/" target="_blank">xpecting their second baby</a> together later this year. The pair are already parents to Charlotte Grace, two.</p>
- Tamzin Outhwaite and Tom Ellis<p> Actress Tamzin is <a href="http://www.parentdish.co.uk/2012/03/19/tamzin-outhwaite-pregnant-with-second-baby-at-41/" target="_blank">expecting her second baby</a> at 41. The former Eastenders actress and husband, Tom Ellis are already proud parents to Florence, four. </p>
Hannah
